Christina at the 50th New York Film Festival
At the 50th New York Film Festival, 2012
Exhibit · New York Film Festival · 2012

Catherine Breillat

The film
Catherine Breillat: The First Time (la première fois), by Luc Moullet
The program
Masterworks: Cinéastes, Cinema of Our Time, Sunday morning, October 7, 2012
The director
Catherine Breillat: writer, novelist, filmmaker, Professor of Auteur Cinema at the European Graduate School
Why it mattered
As a follower of women directors, a wonderful eye-opener
Catherine Breillat
Catherine Breillat
Catherine Breillat making a point
Breillat making a point
Masterworks: Cinéastes, Cinema of Our Time
Masterworks: Cinéastes, Cinema of Our Time, October 3–14

Backstory

On Sunday morning, October 7, at the 50th New York Film Festival, I took in the Masterworks section: an extraordinary behind-the-scenes look at the work of director Catherine Breillat. Who is this woman? Breillat, a writer, novelist, French filmmaker and Professor of Auteur Cinema at the European Graduate School, is bold, bold, bold, and powerful on the subject of female sexuality.

In Luc Moullet’s Catherine Breillat: The First Time, a film critic, her lead actress and her film editor talk about her films, and about the shocking ways she takes on intimacy, gender conflict and sibling rivalry. She has been the subject of controversy for her explicit depictions of sexuality and violence (theater seats were torn up in movie houses), yet she is not considered a porn director by those who worked with her, or by the fans and followers she has gained.

Breillat directed like a silent film director. She talked at length about what she wanted, expected and required until she created a state of tension, and the actors were dropped into it to say their lines, so their reactions came from their actual physical and emotional state. She used stairways instead of bedrooms, explaining that sex on stairs is uncomfortable and hard, with always a chance someone will come upon the lovers. Pauses are important, to make it seem real and not pornographic. The screams in the dark between the pauses… whew.

The editing builds suspense out of everyday tension on the roads, big trucks and cars changing lanes at high speed, until the scene that turns the audience into individual spectators in a dark room with others. It becomes voyeurism en masse, and when unexpected violence breaks the moment of comfort the spectator has settled into, it is a jolting, hyper-real experience.

Breillat said she was a writer first. At 17 she published her novel L’Homme facile, and the French government banned it for readers under 18. A film based on the novel was made soon after, and although it was rated, it could not be released for twenty years: the producer went bankrupt and distribution was blocked. That didn’t stop her. Her body of work includes Romance (1999), Fat Girl (2001), Brief Crossing (2001), Sex Is Comedy (2002) and Anatomy of Hell (2004), still working through theories of sexual power, and in 2010 her second fairy-tale film, Sleeping Beauty, opened in the Orizzonti section of the Venice Film Festival.

Masterworks is classic Film Society of Lincoln Center repertoire: restorations, revivals and rediscoveries from cinema’s past, the way they were meant to be seen on the big screen. It is an excellent sidebar for film students of all ages. For me, as a follower of women directors, it was a wonderful eye-opener on a Sunday morning, and I look forward to seeing more of Catherine Breillat’s bold, bold, bold work.